Feedback & Suggestions for Improving Gameplay/Player Experience

Introduction

Hello everyone from a resident of Sacrament! My name is Kirill.

I would love to say many wonderful things about this amazing game, but time is the most valuable resource in the world, so I’ll try to keep this short. I’ll simply say that I love this wonderful game. A game that has recently earned a special place in my heart.

You can feel the tremendous amount of work and the endless passion that went into creating this universe. I am sincerely grateful for everything you’ve done. You guys are amazing!

After putting in 136 hours, and yes, I actually finished the game after 136 hours, not because I found it particularly difficult (I wouldn’t call it that, even on the highest difficulty, and even when playing co-op), but because I explored every corner of this world and wanted to make the experience last as long as possible.

I was curious like a little child, and that feeling kept pulling me back into the game again and again.

Simply fighting monsters, testing yourself, gathering resources, furnishing your home. All of these things look fantastic and fit together harmoniously. They make you want to keep coming back.

But, as with any good story, there’s another side to the coin, where certain things can be a little controversial.

136 hours, and I have quite a bit to say.

Everything I’m about to describe is nothing more than my personal perspective. I hope I won’t offend the developers or come across as arrogant. Please understand that this is not how I see myself. It’s simply the opinion of an ordinary player who has fallen in love with your incredible project.

I would be more than happy if any of these suggestions could actually help make our shared adventure even more enjoyable!

And yes, perhaps some of these ideas are already planned for release. But we don’t know. :blush:


Additions

1. Additional progression after reaching the maximum level

At the moment, the maximum level is 30, although in a recent video we saw level 45.

I would suggest introducing a system that allows players to continue gaining levels, similar to the Paragon system in Diablo 3/4.

The “Maximum Level” label could be replaced with something else, for example, Ascension, with a level displayed next to it, such as Ascension 1.

The idea is that after fully leveling our character, and perhaps completing a specific quest, we unlock the ability to gain new Ascension levels without receiving any additional character stat improvements.

The reward for each level could be either Ichor (I’ll explain more about Ichor in suggestion 2 below) or another resource that could be exchanged with a vendor for Embers (more about the vendor in suggestion 3 below).

This would also give players a reason to rest at the inn to receive the 10% XP buff.

It would also give us a reason to visit the Alchemist and purchase XP potions from him. Because, honestly, after a certain point, unfortunately, both the Alchemist and the Chef become somewhat underutilized.

At the very least, this mechanic would make fighting mobs, gaining experience, and watching your Ascension level increase feel rewarding.

2. The ability to exchange Ichor for other resources

Add a vendor who allows us to exchange Ichor for Embers, as described in suggestion 1 (more about the vendor in suggestion 3).

For example:

a) Exchange 1 Ichor for 2–3 random Embers.

b) Exchange 2-3 Ichor to replace a component on an item with a random one. A maximum of 3 times per item.

c) Exchange 5–7 Ichor for a random Legendary piece of equipment available to us (something we have already obtained before).

d) Add Ichor as one of the ingredients required to craft a scarecrow.

This would give players a reason to farm Ichor, which currently drops from certain monsters in the open world and can also be obtained from weekly quests (more about quests below).

3. A new NPC and additional activities connected to the Crucible

Once we reach the maximum level, we would need to complete a specific quest given by an NPC. After completing it, we would unlock the ability to gain Ascension levels and would also be able to exchange Ichor for other resources through this NPC.

Alternatively, all of this could be connected to the Crucible.

We complete all available Crucible tiers, defeat the final boss, and receive a Soul Shard as a drop.

During a subsequent run, we could unlock a new NPC at the Crucible vendor on tier 5 by spending this shard. The NPC would then appear in the Crucible lobby.

He thanks us for freeing him, tells us a story about the “Chosen Warriors of Cerim”, and gives us a task: a special trial.

After completing this trial, we unlock the aforementioned Ascension 1 progression.

We could also introduce additional modes in the Crucible that players can activate:

a) Bowels of the Blight

Essentially, this would be an enhanced difficulty mode in which enemies are stronger.

The stronger the enemies, the more Ascension experience we receive, and the better the reward from the final boss/chest.

This mode could be applied to any Crucible tier.

b) Trial of Cerim

After activating this mode, our character becomes completely naked, without any equipment.

Imagine activating this mode through the new NPC. He says:

“Well, as you wish, Cerim. Before you leave, leave all your equipment with me. I’ll look after it. Hopefully, the rats won’t steal anything. I hate rats.”

(We all love these kinds of amusing characters with a sense of humor.)

Once we select this mode and enter the trial, our character appears completely naked. Nearby, there is either a chest or a statue with the following inscription:

“Cerim, your weapon shall show you the way.”

Upon interacting with it, we are offered a choice of 1 out of 3 or 4 random weapons, excluding Legendary weapons.

Perhaps these weapons could even have no enchantments, although I’m not entirely sure about that. :blush:

The idea behind this challenge is that we start with absolutely nothing and gradually progress, equipping ourselves with whatever drops along the way. Only the weapon skills we’ve previously leveled up. This ties into your reworked class system.

Options, we could introduce NPCs at tiers 1, 5, and 10:

  • Level 1: Gives us a weapon of our choice.

  • Level 5: Helps us insert or remove a gem from our weapon or armor.

  • Level 10: Appears at the starting point and also helps us with gems.

Cleansing areas of Blight and completing certain Crucible challenges should reward us with more Ascension experience than simply wandering around the world.

However, the difference shouldn’t be enormous.

4. The ability to exchange Embers for other Embers

Allow players to exchange one type of Ember for another.

For example, 2:1 or 3:1, depending on the rarity of the Ember we need.

In my opinion, Heavenly Embers are among the most valuable resources in the game.

5. More information about active buffs

Add the ability to view detailed information about currently active buffs.

Unfortunately, I couldn’t find this information anywhere.

This would be extremely useful to me, and I know at least a couple of friends who would also appreciate having these details available.

6. More detailed information about stats

a) Equipment

I want to see the minimum and maximum possible values for each individual equipment stat directly in the game, without having to rely on external resources.

For example: Thorns 26%.

When hovering over a stat with the mouse, or through an additional tab when using a gamepad, it would be great to have the option to view the item’s enchantments and see what each one actually means, along with its possible value range.

For example, just like on the build planner at www.norestforthewicked.gg:

Thorns 26% (12%–40%).

I would like to see the minimum and maximum values that can naturally roll on equipment, rather than values after upgrades.

b) Curses on Plagued items

Add an exclamation mark (!) next to the curse on a Plagued item.

When hovering over it, the game would display which curses can appear on that particular item.

c) Character stats

Add the ability to access more detailed information about character stats.

For example, damage:

  • Damage type and its value.

  • Critical hit chance.

  • Critical hit damage.

  • Armor penetration.

  • Base damage.

  • Thorns.

  • And so on.

I don’t know exactly how this will look at release, especially considering the upcoming rework and class system, but I would really appreciate having access to more information.

The build planner on www.norestforthewicked.gg already provides more detailed information than the game itself.

However, honestly, it’s not particularly convenient to rely on external resources for this.

It would be wonderful to have all of this information available directly in the game.

I want to immerse myself completely in the game, and I want the game to be player-friendly when it comes to providing information.

7. An option to adjust the intensity of special effects

Add an option to adjust the intensity of visual effects in the game.

Unfortunately, I couldn’t find such a setting.

I was playing with a friend, and we went into the Crucible. After some time, my eyes started hurting because my friend was using a bow and shooting lightning arrows.

The entire screen was constantly flashing.

At some point, I literally told him:

“Damn, I wish I could actually understand what’s happening on the screen.”

And I was playing a mage myself, if you know what I mean. :blush:


Improvements / Reworks

1. Gathering indicator

The gathering indicator is visually inconvenient and too dim.

I have poor eyesight and wear glasses. I also use an IPS monitor.

I constantly have to strain my eyes and squint just to hit the red zone.

In general, with the current camera angle, it can sometimes be difficult to locate the indicator.

Your eyes naturally try to follow the area where the action is happening, or the center of the screen, rather than the position of your character.

Even after 136 hours of playing, this is still an issue.

For example, when I cast my fishing rod, I instinctively expect the indicator to appear where the catch is happening, rather than near my character.

Overall, the indicator is neat and looks nice, but actually trying to track it is quite hard on the eyes, so to speak.

Especially in the Lowland Meadows area. Trying to spot the indicator there is a real pain for the eyes.

Perhaps adjusting its colors would make it more comfortable to look at.

Right now, the indicator looks rather dim, even on an IPS panel.

2. Prevent accidental gathering actions during combat

Remove the possibility of accidentally starting to gather plants, mine resources, and so on while fighting.

This has caused my death on numerous occasions.

Also, add the ability to cancel a gathering action using the dodge button.

For example:

I’m standing and fishing when enemies suddenly attack me. I don’t know how to cancel the action, and I end up dying.

Intuitively, it would make sense to interrupt the action by pressing the dodge button.

However, the game forces us into a situation where we can accidentally press the interaction button and perform an imperfect gathering action instead.

And even with this mechanic, we can still get hit by enemies.

3. Remove empty weapon slots from weapon switching

When switching weapons, skip empty slots instead of allowing the player to switch to them.

This is incredibly inconvenient.

I can’t even count how many times I’ve died because of this during boss fights.

It gets confusing, especially in the middle of combat.

4. Improve the visual design of buff indicators

The current buff indicators are visually inconvenient.

Let’s take the buff received after resting at our house as an example.

The buff icon itself is unclear, the background is black and white, and the timer is white and semi-transparent, making it difficult to track how much time remains before the buff expires.

One possible solution would be to display the buff timer as a progress bar around the edges of the icon.

For example, a green outline could gradually decrease around the diamond-shaped icon as the buff duration runs out.

This is just an example.

5. Allow the Smelting Furnace to be placed closer to walls

There is too much empty space between the wall and the Smelting Furnace.

This can look rather unattractive in certain layouts, especially when you’re trying to furnish your home nicely.

It would be great if we could place it closer to the wall.

6. Fix incorrect object removal when furnishing houses

Sometimes, when trying to remove an object inside the house, a completely different object gets removed instead.

This is incredibly frustrating, especially when you accidentally remove something important and then have to tear everything down and rebuild it from scratch.

For example:

We select an object to remove, and the game displays the message:

“Remove Small Chest?”

We press YES, but instead of the Small Chest, the game removes something else, for example, the Sawmill.

The Small Chest was positioned nearby, so apparently it somehow falls within the Sawmill’s interaction area.

7. Quests

At a certain point in the game, I noticed that I no longer felt particularly motivated to actively pursue quests.

Of course, I still accept them, and if I happen to complete one naturally, that’s great. If not, it’s no big deal.

Resources, equipment, silver — all of these things drop naturally throughout the game anyway.

The amount of Embers offered as a reward isn’t particularly motivating either.

Ichor? What am I supposed to do with it once my character is fully leveled?

Receiving resources such as Leather or Wood as quest rewards simply isn’t worth my attention personally.

The only rewards that genuinely motivated me to go out of my way and complete quests were Black Pearl and Sublime Ember.

Initially, I used to check equipment enchantments to see what I could extract, and I completed quests once or twice for that reason.

But eventually, I no longer felt the need to do so.

I never really experienced a shortage of equipment.


Ideas

1. Renting out purchased houses

Allow players to rent out their purchased houses.

Tenants could work similarly to vendors, paying us rent once per day.

Possible payment options:

  • Coins.

  • Resources.

We could introduce some randomness so that different tenants sometimes pay in coins and sometimes in resources.

Alternatively, certain events could trigger.

For example, we rent a house to a hunter who occasionally pays us with resources.

He might say:

“Listen, Cerim. I went hunting yesterday and found something rather strange. Thought you might find it useful.”

And then he gives us, for example, 1–2 random Embers.

You might think that this would create too many sources for obtaining Embers:

a) Open-world loot.

b) Daily/weekly quests.

c) Exchanging Ichor with a vendor (suggestion).

d) Tenants (suggestion).

Houses available for rent can also be upgraded, just like the one we live in. The rent depends on the level of comfort.


Some Random Thoughts

You can never have too many Heavenly Embers.

In my opinion, this is still a late-game mechanic, when we start putting together specific builds at a more advanced stage of the game.

Let me tell you a little story about how I spent 80 Embers, which I had been farming for 7 days, in literally 2–3 minutes, trying to change a single property on a Plagued armor piece.

The property I wanted never dropped because, as it turns out, Parry Disabled can only appear on gloves.

Who knew? :blush:

Or here’s another little story.

13 Royal Chests in a row. Zero Heavenly Embers. :blush:

I wouldn’t say that farming resources so heavily in a game that isn’t even an MMO is particularly enjoyable.

Creating several additional realms, running the same farming routes over and over again, and figuring out everyone’s different farming methods…

Of course, the overall idea of resource farming in this game is really great, and I genuinely enjoy it.

However, such an intense grind for Embers can make the game feel a little tedious and take away some of the enjoyment.

After spending an entire month completely absorbed in the game (I took a very long time to complete the campaign because I love exploring everything), I eventually reached a point where I would simply go fishing or chop down trees.

And then, at some point, I realized that I needed Heavenly Embers.

Coming home from work and spending my evening running through different realms, farming them over and over again, doesn’t really feel like entertainment or relaxation.

It feels more like taking on a second routine job that I don’t particularly want to come back to.

And the appearance of the leather helmets leaves much to be desired :sweat_smile:


Final Thoughts

That’s everything from me.

It turned out to be a little less concise than I originally intended, but I tried my best not to include unnecessary details.

This isn’t a call to action or an instruction manual. It’s simply my feedback and personal observations about things that would make my own experience (since I can’t speak on behalf of everyone) in this wonderful game even more enjoyable!

Once again, thank you for all your hard work!

With love from Russia!

Lara forever <3

Im sure a lot of these mechanics and game systems will change for 1.0, at least from what we’ve seen in the wicked inside, will just have to wait for the open beta and more wicked inside just so see what really has changed.

though i cant agree with the Paragon system, i also think it goes agents their views of “just put a few points in to something but not feeling much of a different after” like the current attribute system that there removing for 1.0 new systems.

but i hope they do make something that dose feel meaningful even after getting to level 60. like unlocking more cores when you get to end game. xD

Hi! Thanks for your comment. Regarding the paragon system, I’m not entirely sure it makes sense to keep upgrading the character once you reach the max level, since this isn’t an MMO like Diablo or PoE after all. Though who knows what it might evolve into. However, continuing to level up as a mechanic for farming and getting Ichor for trading or Embers would be great.
I think I’ll edit my feedback and add:
Since we’re getting guilds anyway, we could tie this to them. Once you hit max level, you complete a guild bounty, and after that, you start earning guild reputation levels. For each level gained, we could claim some kind of reward from an NPC in the guild or from a special chest. Then again, maybe it will actually be implemented like that. Or they could even separate it into Crucible reputation levels and Guild reputation.

Other than that, I agree—we generally need to wait for the release. Still, maybe the developers can take away something useful from the feedback, and I’d be more than happy to help.