I know there are already a lot of different threads regarding the attribute system, but i think most of the issues with the current system (weapon requirements, attributes feeling unfullfilling, etc.) could be solved by one rather radical but in my opinion reasonable change: Strength, Dexterity, In…

I agree with you. I think having STR. INT. DEX and FTH without really representing those stats are really misleading. STR does not represent the strength of a character. It represents what weapons you can wield and its damage. Same for other stats. Check out my feedback here [image] …

The problem is that its hard to have meaningful decisions combined with “i can do everything at anytime”. I personally like final stats because that is what my character has become and i have to deal with that. Boundaries are important to make your decisions meaningful. And its about to become som…

This isn’t the first time it’s been suggested, merging the main attributes into one, and I doubt it will be the last. I think the current system could be fixed if Moon were more strict on what weapons get what attributes. If you want to use a greatsword, you go into STR and that’s that. If you’re a…

I understand that merging all of those stats into one most probably create more problems than a solution. check my post a bit above this one. But locking weapons to stats like that would be against devs vision. They want to create a “soft class” systems where player can chose and experiment whateve…

I think its not about using a weapon, its more about handling one. More realism: If somebody gives me a hammer or sword could hold it in my hand and try something out, but i CANNOT handle it at this point. I have to learn how to handle it. This is why i also think it would be good to remove the …

going to respectfully disagree. Your idea would work, i question the snowball effect it would have on longevity and experimentation If we had a single attribute ( might or aggression are both great names btw) , why would i try different weapons? Try different play styles ? Imagine an archer focus…

While I agree with you wholeheartedly, I think the current system doesn’t really reach that anyway. It merely creates that illusion of flexibility. For example, a character with 42 str with sword that requires str and a character with 42 int with another sword that requires int at current state does…

aah, that makes sense - i like it. so different attributes should be felt in the weapon choice and fighting style? Question … would that not lead us to an “informal” class system? a barbarian by another name there is something here though. a way to keep the vision of the game ( true classless) a…

I think Attributes don’t have to be complex, to work more in the way you describe (also like Elden Ring as an example). We could simply merge the Attributes we already have :upside_down_face: Strength = Equip Load Intelligence = Focus Dexterity = Stamina Faith = Health But in all seriousness.…

good points and questions raised. count me in how do we get eyes on this ?

Remove classic rpg-style attributes to increase build-flexibility

Wicked Feedback

Pheromoon May 6, 2024, 11:26am 86

Yes, I touched some of that ideas here, but I also can’t deny that my suggestion still needs some work.

Topic		Replies	Views
Remove Weapon Stat Scaling and Requirements Wicked Feedback suggestions	11	567	April 29, 2024
Stats System needs rework Wicked Feedback	10	890	October 15, 2024
A change to Stats improving "classless" gameplay Wicked Feedback suggestions	30	765	May 8, 2024
First Preview of our Class System Wicked General	197	44131	February 12, 2026
Detailed Feedback After 40 Hours Wicked Feedback	61	1851	April 29, 2024

Remove classic rpg-style attributes to increase build-flexibility

Related topics